IL (847) 278-2272
WI (414) 662-9550

The Pros & Cons Of Composite Roof Tiles

Does your head spin with the multitude of roofing materials available when considering a roof replacement? One popular choice is composite roof tiles by DaVinci Roofscapes. They have specialized in manufacturing composite and synthetic shake and slate roofing products for over 20 years.

This article will highlight the pros and cons of composite roofing material, enabling you to make an informed decision when choosing your next roof.

Pros of Composite Roof Tiles

Composite roof tiles offer numerous advantages. They are eco-friendly, made from recycled materials, and can be recycled themselves. The durability of composite roof tiles is impressive, withstanding harsh weather conditions and resisting damage better than traditional materials.

They are cost-effective compared to natural slate roof tiles, providing the same aesthetic appeal at a fraction of the price.


composite roofing shingles on house

Composite roof tiles lead the way in eco-friendly roofing options. These tiles are fashioned from sustainable resources like recycled plastics and rubber. This manufacturing process minimizes waste, making it a green solution for your home.

Their durability means less need for replacement, reducing landfill contributions. Composite roof materials have great insulation properties, which can significantly decrease energy consumption by regulating indoor temperatures effectively.


Composite roof tiles prove their worth over time. Their durability is exceptional and unmatched in the roofing industry. They stand strong against harsh weather conditions, from fierce winds to bitter hailstorms.

Besides enduring nature’s elements, these tiles show incredible resistance to fire hazards, giving homeowners peace of mind knowing their properties are safe. The lifespan of composite tiles is impressively long thanks to all these fortifying qualities; even after years under the sun or storm, they barely display wear and tear!

Plus, warranties on these sturdy warriors are extended, making them a reliable choice for any home during roof replacement.

Cost-Effective Compared To Real Slate

Opting for composite slate is a smart, cost-saving decision over real slate. While the upfront expenditure may seem more, you’ll find that it is still significantly cheaper than real slate.

Synthetic slate roofing costs $9 to $12 per square foot installed on average, almost half the amount of authentic slate tiles. These roof replacements authentically replicate the natural aesthetic and texture of genuine natural slate and provide exceptional durability without burning a hole in your pocket.

So homeowners who crave the natural elegance of traditional slates can get more value for their money with composite tiles! This makes it an appealing alternative when considering full on roof tile replacement options.

Cons of Composite Roof Tiles

While they may be more cost-effective in the long run, the initial investment can deter some homeowners. Also, composite roof tiles are relatively new to the industry, so there may be limited information and experience available compared to other roofing options.

Expensive Upfront Cost

Composite roof tiles may come with an expensive upfront cost compared to other roofing materials. On average, composite roofing costs are higher than asphalt and architectural shingles, making it a significant investment for homeowners.

Concrete or clay tile roofing is generally even more expensive than asphalt shingles, with clay roofs costing between $30,000 and $51,000 on average.

While the initial expense of composite roof tile might be off-putting, it’s essential to consider the long-term benefits and durability of composite roof tiles for a sustainable and cost-effective solution in the future.

Relatively New to the Industry

Composite roof tiles are a recent addition to the roofing industry. These tiles, made from plastic, rubber, and recycled materials, offer homeowners an alternative to traditional roofing options.

While they may not be as well-known as concrete or clay tiles, composite roof tiles have gained popularity recently due to their durability and eco-friendly nature. With advancements in technology and manufacturing processes, these tiles are becoming more widely available and affordable for homeowners looking for a long-lasting and sustainable roofing option.

Although relatively new to the market, composite roof tiles show promise as an innovative solution for those seeking a modern twist on traditional roofing materials.

Comparing Composite Roof Tiles to Other Roof Types

top view of house roof

When comparing composite roof tiles to other roof types, such as other concrete tiles and clay tiles, shingle roofs, and wood roofing, it’s important to consider factors like durability, cost-effectiveness, and environmental impact.

Composite roof tiles offer a viable alternative that is both eco-friendly and durable. Concrete and clay tiles provide a traditional aesthetic but can be heavy and expensive. Shingle roofs are affordable but may not have the same lifespan as composite tiles.

Wood roofing offers natural beauty but requires more maintenance.

Concrete and Clay Tiles

Concrete and clay tiles are popular roof materials due to their durability and unique style. Both options offer long-lasting home protection, considered more durable than most roofing materials.

Clay tiles, in particular, are known for their energy efficiency and long lifespan. While concrete and clay tiles can be heavier and more costly than other options, they provide a distinct aesthetic appeal that can enhance the value of a home.

Whether you prefer the classic look of clay or the versatility of concrete, these tile options offer reliable durability and exceptional style for your roof.

Shingle Roofs

Shingle roofs are a popular choice for many homeowners. Made from asphalt or composite materials, shingle roofs offer a lower cost and easier installation compared to tile roofs. They are more common than tile roofs and have a shorter lifespan.

Shingle roofs are less durable than tile roofs and are less resistant to fire and extreme weather conditions. Despite these limitations, composite shingles remain attractive for those looking for affordability and ease of installation.

Wood Roofing

Wood roofing is a traditional option that many homeowners consider when choosing a new roof. It provides a classic and natural look that some people prefer over composite roof tiles.

One important factor to consider is its lifespan; composite roofing material and tiles generally have a longer lifespan than wood roofing.

Additionally, wood roofing may require more maintenance and upkeep compared to composite roof tiles. There can be concerns with rot, mold, and insect damage with wood roofing as well.

Composite Roof Tiles Are a Great Choice

Composite roof tiles offer numerous benefits for homeowners. They are eco-friendly, durable, and cost-effective compared to real slate roofs, and they have the same beautiful look. These lightweight tiles have extreme weather resistance and have a long lifespan of 30-50 years.

With their resistance to mold and rot, they require minimal maintenance. Homeowners also have the flexibility to choose from various colors and designs to match their desired aesthetic.

Shake Guys are proud members of the DaVinci Masterpiece Contractor program. We also install Brava and EcoStar composite roofing. Our certified installers work with Chicagoland and Wisconsin homeowners. Contact our team for excellent service if you want to install composite shake davinci shingles for your next roof.

Schedule a Free Inspection & Consultation