Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing vs Natural Cedar
Choosing the right roofing material for your home is a major decision. It’s not just about aesthetics; you need to consider durability, cost, and longevity. One of the more popular options in recent years is synthetic cedar shake roofing. But how does it compare to the real thing?
This blog post will provide a detailed comparison between synthetic cedar shake roofing and natural cedar shake, focusing on:
- Durability
- Cost
- Looks
- Longevity
By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of why synthetic cedar shake roofing might be the ideal choice for your home.
What is Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing?
Synthetic cedar shake roofing is a man-made product designed to replicate the look and feel of natural cedar shakes. These synthetic shakes are typically made from a combination of materials, including rubber, plastics, and other high-performance polymers. The goal is to offer a product that mimics the beauty of natural wood without the drawbacks associated with organic material.
💪 Durability
Natural Cedar Shake
Natural cedar shakes are known for their rustic beauty and natural insulating properties. However, their durability can be a concern. Cedar is a type of softwood, which makes it susceptible to weathering, rot, and insect damage. Over time, exposure to the elements can cause the wood to crack, split, or warp. Regular maintenance, including treatments for mold and mildew, is necessary to keep natural cedar shakes in good condition.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
On the other hand, synthetic cedar shakes are engineered to withstand harsh weather conditions. They are resistant to moisture, rot, and insect damage. Unlike natural wood, synthetic materials do not warp, split, or crack. Many synthetic shakes also come with Class 4 impact resistance and Class A fire ratings, making them extremely durable and safe. In environments prone to extreme weather, synthetic cedar shakes offer a level of resilience that natural wood cannot match.
💰 Cost
Initial Cost
The initial cost of natural cedar shake roofing can be quite high. Quality cedar wood is expensive, and the installation process is labor-intensive, adding to the overall cost. On average, natural cedar shake roofing can range from $6 to $12 per square foot, including materials and labor.
Synthetic cedar shake roofing is generally more affordable in terms of both material and installation costs. Prices typically range from $4 to $8 per square foot. While this is still a significant investment, the lower cost of materials and easier installation can make synthetic options more financially accessible for many homeowners.
Long-term Costs
When considering long-term costs, natural cedar shakes may require frequent maintenance and repairs. Treatments for mold, mildew, and insect damage can add up over the years. In contrast, synthetic cedar shakes require minimal maintenance, which translates to lower long-term costs. Additionally, the longer lifespan of synthetic shakes means fewer replacements over time, further reducing expenses.
🪞Appearance
Natural Cedar Shake
Natural cedar shakes have a unique, rustic charm that is hard to replicate. The natural variations in color and grain give each shake a distinctive look. Over time, natural cedar weathers to a beautiful silvery-gray patina, adding to its aesthetic appeal. For many homeowners, the authentic look and feel of natural wood are worth the extra cost and maintenance.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Advancements in manufacturing have made it possible to create synthetic cedar shakes that closely mimic the appearance of natural wood. High-quality synthetic shakes feature realistic textures and colors that can fool even the most discerning eye. Some manufacturers offer a range of colors and styles, allowing homeowners to choose the exact look they want. While synthetic shakes do not change color over time, they are designed to maintain their appearance for years without fading.
⏰ Longevity
Natural Cedar Shake
The lifespan of natural cedar shake roofing can vary widely depending on factors like climate, maintenance, and the quality of the wood. On average, natural cedar shakes last between 20 to 30 years. However, in harsh climates or without proper maintenance, their lifespan can be significantly shorter.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes are designed for longevity. Most products come with warranties of 50 years or more, reflecting their long-lasting durability. The materials used in synthetic shakes are resistant to the elements that typically shorten the lifespan of natural wood, such as moisture and UV radiation. This means synthetic cedar shake roofing can provide decades of reliable service with minimal upkeep.
🌎 Environmental Impact
Natural Cedar Shake
Natural cedar shakes are biodegradable and sourced from renewable forests, making them an environmentally friendly option. However, the harvesting process can contribute to deforestation if not managed sustainably. Additionally, the treatments required to preserve natural wood can introduce chemicals into the environment.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
While synthetic cedar shakes are made from non-biodegradable materials, many manufacturers use recycled or recyclable materials in their products. The longer lifespan and reduced need for chemical treatments make synthetic shakes a more sustainable option over time. Some companies also implement eco-friendly manufacturing processes, further reducing their environmental footprint.
🔨 Installation
Natural Cedar Shake
Installing natural cedar shakes is a labor-intensive process that requires skilled craftsmanship. Each shake must be individually nailed in place, and the uneven nature of the wood can make installation more challenging. This complexity adds to the installation cost and time.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes are designed for easier installation. They are typically lighter and more uniform in size and shape, allowing for quicker and more straightforward installation. Some synthetic shakes come with interlocking systems or pre-drilled holes, further simplifying the process. This not only reduces labor costs but also shortens the installation timeline.
⛅️ Weather Resistance
Natural Cedar Shake
Natural cedar shakes provide a decent level of weather resistance, but they are not impervious to the elements. Prolonged exposure to moisture can lead to rot and mold growth. Insects, particularly termites, can also pose a threat. While cedar has some natural resistance to pests, it is not foolproof.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes excel in weather resistance. They are impervious to moisture, preventing issues like rot and mold. The synthetic materials are also unattractive to insects, eliminating the risk of pest damage. Many synthetic shakes are designed to withstand extreme weather conditions, including high winds and heavy rain, making them an excellent choice for regions with harsh climates.
⚡️Energy Efficiency
Natural Cedar Shake
Cedar wood has natural insulating properties that can help regulate indoor temperatures. This can contribute to energy savings by reducing the need for heating and cooling. However, the gaps and irregularities in natural shakes can reduce their overall energy efficiency.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes can be engineered to offer superior energy efficiency. Some products include built-in insulation layers or reflective coatings that enhance their thermal performance. This can result in greater energy savings and a more comfortable living environment. Additionally, the uniformity of synthetic shakes ensures a tighter seal, further improving energy efficiency.
⚙️ Customization Options
Natural Cedar Shake
With natural cedar, customization options are limited to the natural variation in color and texture. While this can create a unique, one-of-a-kind look, it also means less control over the final appearance of the roof. Homeowners who prefer a specific aesthetic may find it challenging to achieve with natural wood.
Synthetic Cedar Shake
Synthetic cedar shakes offer a wide range of customization options. Manufacturers provide various colors, finishes, and styles to suit different architectural preferences. Some products even allow homeowners to mix and match colors for a personalized look. This level of customization makes it easier to achieve the desired aesthetic while maintaining the benefits of synthetic materials.
Install Your Synthetic Cedar Shake Roof
When comparing synthetic cedar shake roofing to natural cedar shake, it’s clear that synthetic options offer several advantages. They are more durable, cost-effective, and require less maintenance. Synthetic shakes also provide excellent weather resistance, energy efficiency, and customization options. While the authentic look and feel of natural cedar may be appealing, the practical benefits of synthetic cedar shake roofing make it a superior choice for many homeowners.
If you’re considering upgrading your roof, take the time to explore synthetic cedar shake options. You’ll find that they offer the perfect blend of beauty, durability, and affordability. Ready to make the switch? Contact our team today to learn more about how synthetic cedar shake roofing can enhance your home.